Spicy Jamaican jerk chicken piled into a soft roll with a cooling citrus yogurt sauce.
Jerk chicken is Jamaica's most famous culinary export, defined by a fiery marinade of scotch bonnet, allspice (pimento), thyme, and scallion, traditionally smoked slowly over pimento wood. This sandwich takes that same bold jerk flavor and tucks it into a soft roll, cooled down with a bright citrus yogurt sauce that tempers the marinade's heat. The technique that matters most for real jerk flavor is marinating time -- at least 4 hours, ideally overnight, so the allspice and scotch bonnet properly penetrate the chicken -- and cooking it over indirect heat so the outside chars without the inside drying out or the sugars in the marinade burning. A yogurt sauce brightened with lime and orange zest, stirred together while the chicken cooks, gives the sandwich a cooling contrast that balances the marinade's heat. Served on a soft roll with pickled vegetables or coleslaw, this jerk chicken sandwich takes an iconic Caribbean dish and makes it portable, keeping the essential smoky heat while adding the citrus yogurt as a genuinely useful cooling element.
Serves 5
Blend scotch bonnet, scallions, allspice, soy sauce, brown sugar, oil, garlic, and half the lime juice into a paste.
Rub the marinade over the chicken thighs and marinate in the fridge at least 4 hours, ideally overnight.
Mix yogurt with orange zest and remaining lime juice.
Grill or pan-sear the chicken over medium-high heat, 5-6 minutes per side, until charred and cooked through (74°C/165°F internal).
Let the chicken rest 5 minutes, then slice.
Toast the rolls, layer with shredded cabbage, sliced jerk chicken, and a generous spoonful of citrus yogurt sauce.
Marinate overnight if at all possible -- jerk flavor depends on real time for the allspice and chili to penetrate the meat.
Handle scotch bonnets with gloves and avoid touching your face -- they're extremely hot.
Cook over medium-high, not blazing heat, so the sugar in the marinade caramelizes without burning before the chicken cooks through.
Grill over charcoal, ideally with pimento wood chips, for the most authentic smoky jerk flavor.
Use chicken breast for a leaner sandwich, watching cook time closely since it dries out faster.
Add pickled Scotch bonnet slices to the sandwich for those who want extra heat.
Refrigerate cooked jerk chicken up to 3 days. Reheat gently to avoid drying it out; assemble sandwiches fresh.
Jerk cooking originated with the Maroons, escaped enslaved Africans who settled in Jamaica's mountains and developed the technique of seasoning and slow-smoking meat over pimento wood, a method that has since become globally recognized as distinctly Jamaican.
Habanero peppers are the closest substitute in heat and fruitiness, though scotch bonnet has a slightly different, more floral flavor.
Yes, marinate and cook the chicken up to 3 days ahead, then reheat gently and assemble fresh.
Add more scotch bonnet to the marinade, including some seeds, which carry much of the heat -- taste the marinade paste before applying it.
Per serving (224g / 7.9 oz) · 5 servings total
Ask our AI cooking assistant anything about this recipe — substitutions, techniques, scaling.
Chat with AI Chef →Join the conversation
Sign in to leave a comment and save your favourite recipes
Have feedback or need help?
We read every email and reply within 1–2 business days.
© 2026 MyCookingCalendar. All rights reserved.
