Butter Substitutes for Baking: Oil, Margarine, Applesauce, and Shortening Compared
Every butter substitute trades off crumb, spread, and moisture differently — here's the real ratio and texture impact for oil, margarine, applesauce, coconut oil, and shortening.
Butter does more structural work in baking than most substitutes account for. It's about 80% fat and 15-17% water, and that water content contributes steam during baking that helps things like pie crust and puff pastry flake. Its solid-at-room-temperature structure is also what allows creaming with sugar to trap air bubbles that leaven cakes and cookies. Swap it for a substitute with different fat content, water content, or melting behavior, and you'll change spread, crumb density, moisture, and shelf life — sometimes for better, sometimes for worse, but never identically. Understanding what butter's fat and water are actually doing in a given recipe (creaming vs. lamination vs. simple moisture) is the key to picking a substitute that won't wreck the result.
Best Overall Substitute: Neutral Oil (Use About 3/4 the Amount)
For 1 cup of butter, use about 3/4 cup (12 tablespoons) of a neutral oil like vegetable, canola, or light olive oil — oil is 100% fat with no water, so you need less of it to match butter's actual fat content. Oil-based baked goods come out notably more moist and tender since oil coats flour proteins more thoroughly than solid butter, but they lose the light, airy structure that comes from creaming solid butter with sugar, and cookies made with oil spread more and stay flatter.
💡 Tip: Oil works best in recipes already designed around it (like most quick breads and muffins) — don't swap it into a recipe that explicitly calls for creaming butter and sugar, since oil can't trap air the same way.
Margarine (Closest 1:1 Structural Match)
Stick margarine (not the tub/spreadable kind, which has too much added water and air) substitutes 1:1 for butter by volume and behaves most similarly in creaming, spreading, and overall structure, since it's engineered to mimic butter's solid-fat behavior. Flavor is noticeably less rich since margarine lacks butter's milk solids, and cookies made with margarine often spread slightly more due to a lower melting point.
Unsweetened Applesauce (Best for Moisture, Worst for Richness)
Applesauce can replace up to half the butter in many quick breads, muffins, and some cakes — swap 1/2 cup of the butter called for with 1/2 cup applesauce and keep the rest as butter. Replacing all the butter with applesauce produces a noticeably denser, gummier, less rich result since you lose both fat's tenderizing effect and any creaming structure; it works best as a partial swap for a lower-fat version, not a full substitute.
Coconut Oil (Best Vegan 1:1 Swap for Structure)
Refined coconut oil (unflavored) substitutes 1:1 for butter by volume and, unlike liquid oils, is solid at room temperature, so it creams with sugar in a genuinely similar way, making it one of the better vegan options for cookies and cakes that need structure. It has a lower melting point than butter, so cookies can spread more, and refined coconut oil is flavor-neutral while virgin/unrefined coconut oil carries a distinct coconut taste that will come through in the finished product.
Shortening (Best for Flaky Texture, Worst for Flavor)
Vegetable shortening substitutes 1:1 for butter and, because it's 100% fat with a higher melting point and no water, produces exceptionally tender, flaky pie crusts and taller, less-spread cookies. The tradeoff is flavor — shortening is essentially flavorless, so baked goods lose butter's characteristic richness. Many bakers use a half-and-half blend of butter and shortening in pie crust specifically to get both the flakiness of shortening and the flavor of butter.
💡 Tip: For pie crust, a 50/50 butter-shortening blend by weight is a common professional trick — it isn't a pure substitution but gives the best of both textures.
What NOT to Do
Don't substitute a fully liquid oil in any recipe that requires creaming softened butter with sugar to build a leavened structure, like classic butter cookies or pound cake — you'll get a flat, greasy result. Don't use spreadable tub margarine as a 1:1 butter replacement in baking, since its higher water and air content throws off both structure and moisture balance. And don't replace all the butter with applesauce in a recipe meant to be rich, like shortbread or a butter cake, since you'll lose both fat content and flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use oil instead of butter in cookies?
You can, but the texture changes — oil-based cookies spread more, come out flatter and denser, and lose the light, airy crumb that comes from creaming solid butter with sugar. Use about 3/4 the volume of oil as butter, and expect a chewier, less structured cookie.
Is margarine healthier than butter as a substitute?
It depends on the margarine — many modern stick margarines are lower in saturated fat than butter, but some older formulations contain trans fats, which are worse for health than butter's saturated fat. Check the label for zero grams of trans fat, and note margarine still has essentially the same calorie count as butter.
How much applesauce replaces one cup of butter?
Applesauce works best as a partial substitute — replace up to half the butter (1/2 cup applesauce for 1/2 cup of the 1 cup called for) and keep the rest as butter. Replacing all of it produces a noticeably denser, gummier texture since applesauce can't replicate butter's fat-based tenderizing or creaming ability.
What is the best butter substitute for pie crust?
Shortening produces the flakiest crust because its higher melting point and lack of water creates larger, more distinct fat pockets during baking. Many bakers use a 50/50 blend of butter and shortening to combine shortening's flakiness with butter's flavor, since shortening alone is fairly flavorless.
There's no perfect butter substitute — each one trades a different quality. Oil gives moisture but loses airy structure, margarine matches structure but not flavor, applesauce cuts fat but adds density, coconut oil creams well but can taste of coconut, and shortening flakes beautifully but tastes flat. Pick based on what the recipe needs most: rise, richness, or moisture.
Cook this hands-free
Get AI meal plans, step-by-step cooking mode, and your saved recipes in the free Bento app.
Plan your meals, track fasting and build your grocery list — free
MyCookingCalendar's dashboard runs right in your browser, no download needed.